tongue in cheek—that an evangelical is simply someone who admires Billy Graham! All of this skepticism and infighting leaves hard-driving Calvinists such as Michael Horton and D. G. Hart complaining, in Horton’s words, that “quarrels over the evangelical trademark are probably a profound waste of time and precious energy,” or in Hart’s, that “evangelicalism needs to be relinquished as a religious identity because it does not exist.”10 Horton and Hart, like many other erstwhile evangelical leaders,